15 Oct 2023

Lebanon army blames Israel for journalist's killing; Reuters urges probe

1:37 pm on 15 October 2023
Mourners carry the flag-draped casket of Lebanese Reuters video journalist Issam Abdallah, who died on 13 October during Israeli shelling at the Alma al-Shaab border village with Israel.

Mourners carry the flag-draped casket of Lebanese Reuters video journalist Issam Abdallah, who died on 13 October during Israeli shelling at the Alma al-Shaab border village with Israel. Photo: AFP/ Fadel Itani

Lebanon's army says Israel fired a missile that killed a Reuters journalist in southern Lebanon, with a Lebanese military source saying the country had conducted a technical on-the-ground assessment after the attack, which supported its claim.

The Lebanese military source also said the army had concluded the shell was fired by Israel based on observation by Lebanese army patrols in the area at the time of the incident. The source was not authorised to speak to media and spoke to Reuters on condition of anonymity.

"The Israeli enemy launched a missile which hit a civilian car belonging to a media group, which led to the martyrdom of the videographer Issam Abdallah," the Lebanese army high command said in a statement posted on its website.

Reuters, in a statement, said: "We call on the IDF (Israel Defence Forces) to conduct a thorough, swift and transparent investigation. It is critically important for journalists to be able to report freely and safely."

Reuters video journalist Abdallah was killed while working with other journalists near the village of Alma al-Shaab, close to the Israeli border, where the Israeli military and Lebanese militia Hezbollah have been trading fire.

The Israeli military did not immediately respond to the claims made by Lebanon or to a request for comment on the Reuters statement, which was signed by President Paul Bascobert and Editor-in-Chief Alessandra Galloni.

Israeli army spokesman Lt Col Richard Hecht earlier told a regular briefing that it was looking into the incident, adding: "We already have visuals. We're doing cross examination. It's a tragic thing."

A Reuters witness at the scene said Abdallah, a Lebanese national, was struck by missiles fired from the direction of Israel.

State media earlier reported that Lebanon would submit a formal complaint to the UN Security Council on "Israel's deliberate killing" of Abdallah.

Foreign Minister Abdallah Bou Habib later confirmed, without elaborating, that the complaint said Israel had targeted journalists with "direct bombardment", which had resulted in Issam Abdallah's death.

While other news outlets, including the Associated Press and Al Jazeera, said the shells were Israeli, Reuters has not established that the missiles had been fired by Israel or that Israel was intentionally targeting the journalists.

Countries regularly write to the 15-member Security Council to register complaints and it is unlikely the body will take any action.

Funeral

Abdallah was buried on Saturday. His body, covered in a Lebanese flag, was carried in a procession attended by hundreds of mourners through his home town of Khiyam in southern Lebanon. Journalists placed their cameras on the grave to honour his memory and prayers were said.

"They were sitting where there was no shelling, nothing. They were filming the shelling from afar. Why would they bomb them?" said Abdallah's mother Fatima Kanso at the funeral, blaming Israel for her son's death.

Abdallah was with two other Reuters journalists, Maher Nazeh and Thaer Al-Sudani, as well as journalists from media groups Al Jazeera and Agence France-Presse, when he was killed while providing a live video signal for broadcasters.

Nazeh and Sudani were both injured in the incident but were later released from the hospital. Agence France-Presse and Al Jazeera each said two of their journalists were wounded in the incident.

Nazeh said they were filming missile fire coming from the direction of Israel when one struck Abdallah as he was sitting on a low stone wall near the rest of the group. Seconds later, another missile hit a car being used by the group, setting it aflame, he said.

UNIFIL, the UN peacekeeping force in southern Lebanon, said it could not say with certainty at this stage how the group of journalists was hit. However, it said it knew that Israel had struck a position 2.5km outside Alma al-Shaab at 5:20 pm (1320GMT).

The Reuters statement said it had requested Israeli assurances that Reuters journalists and offices in the Gaza Strip would not be targeted in Israeli military operations there.

Israeli forces are massing tanks and troops on the border with the southern enclave in preparation for a possible ground invasion. They are fighting a war with Gaza's Hamas militants who launched a deadly assault on Israeli civilians and soldiers a week ago.

- This story was originally published by Reuters

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs