27 Nov 2022

The Week in Detail: COP27, Te Urewera, and Make It 16

From The Detail, 3:00 pm on 27 November 2022

Every weekday, The Detail makes sense of the big news stories.

This week, we looked at the legacy of COP27, the risks facing New Zealand's treasure trove of fossils, the dispute over historic huts in Te Urewera, why dental care costs so much, and how governments go about setting ages for things like voting.

Whakarongo mai to any episodes you might have missed.

COP27 and the fraught reality of climate change negotiations

This year's UN climate summit was always going to be fraught. 

The location, for starters, was Egypt: a country where the sort of political protest commonplace among climate activists isn't exactly looked on favourably. More than 45,000 delegates turned up to a country housing at least as many political prisoners.

Pacific Islands activists protest demanding climate action and loss and damage reparations at COP27 in Egypt

Pacific Islands activists protest demanding climate action and loss and damage reparations at COP27 in Egypt Photo: DOMINIKA ZARZYCKA/AFP

Then there was the geopolitical backdrop: as well as the invasion of Ukraine, many of 193 countries at the conference have been ravaged by economic and social cost of Covid-19, and are engaging in what, in the eyes of much of the public, appears a long-winded exercise in tortured bureaucratese. 

Emile Donovan speaks to Newsroom's Rod Oram, who was on the ground at COP27.

NZ's prehistoric past at risk of crumbling away

When palaeontologist Dr Nic Rawlence pulled a giant ice-age moa skeleton out of a South Island swamp, he knew the marks on its pelvis bone would tell the story of how it died.

Burial in the ancient sea of Zealandia: a Toipahautea whale skeleton is slowly covered by sand 27-28 million years ago, on its path to become a fossil

Burial in the ancient sea of Zealandia: a Toipahautea whale skeleton is slowly covered by sand 27-28 million years ago, on its path to become a fossil Photo: Reconstruction by Chris Gaskin, ©Geology Museum, University of Otago

They were rip marks from the talons of a Haast's eagle, which became extinct around 1400.

But he warns Aotearoa is losing fossils faster than they can be found and preserved, as sites are eroded "in front of our eyes".

Part of the problem, he says, is New Zealand's small and ageing community of professional palaeontologists and amateur 'rockhounds', who go fossil hunting to build their own collections, or sell to museums or private collectors.

Sharon Brettkelly talks to Rawlence about the past, present and future of New Zealand fossils.

The stoush in Te Urewera that's about more than just huts

Deep in Te Urewera sit 19 huts tagged for demolition. They are to be replaced with buildings designed to represent a new era in the ancient forest, a decision made by Tūhoe leadership.

Twenty-nine others have already been dismantled and burnt, but a court injunction from Tūhoe iwi members has stopped the rest of the work.

One of the Department of Conservation back country huts in Te Urewera given historic status within the department, Waiotukapiti Hut, is a rare totara-slab hut built in the 1950s by the Department of Internal Affairs as a base for deer cullers.

One of the Department of Conservation back country huts in Te Urewera, Waiotukapiti Hut. It was used as a base for deer cullers.  Photo: Supplied / Pete Shaw

Sharon Brettkelly speaks to The Hui reporter John Boynton and RNZ's Māori news director Jamie Tahana about the tensions in Tūhoe.

"The huts have been a way for whānau to connect with Te Urewera. They might be DOC buildings, but I think the community and Tūhoe have given them life. It's been their way to hunt and have that relationship with the ngahere," says Boynton.

The inconvenient tooth about a trip to the dentist

Once you turn 18, you're on your own when it comes to looking after your teeth.

Unlike other parts of the health system, the government doesn't subsidise dental care for adults, meaning a trip to the dentist can put a serious dent in people's pockets.

A dentist performs dental work.

A dentist performs dental work. Photo: Supplied

Earlier this month, the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS) released a report that found 40 percent of New Zealanders can't afford dental care. 

Emile Donovan speaks to ASMS chief executive Sarah Dalton, Dental Association president Erin Collins, and University of Otago professor of dental public health Jonathan Broadbent about how dental care became such an expensive part of life.

How old is old enough?

The legal age to buy alcohol has flipped and flopped since 1881 - first 16, then up to 21, then back down to 20 - until we wound up with where we are now, with 18 years of age.

All this to say, age limits on rights and privileges are dynamic. They change over time.

Group of young people outside court building in Auckland, one holding an orange placard that reads 'Make it 16'

Members of Make It 16 after their case was heard in the Supreme Court Photo: Make It 16

With the Supreme Court's ruling that New Zealand's age limit on voting is unjustified discrimination hot off the presses, Emile Donovan speaks to legal expert John Ip and politics professor Richard Shaw about how governments set ages for different civic milestones.

Find out how to listen and subscribe to The Detail here.  

You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter

Photo: